Skip to content
Home » Least Abrasive Toothpaste: RDA Chart and Toothbrush Abrasion

Least Abrasive Toothpaste: RDA Chart and Toothbrush Abrasion

Quick answer

To find the least abrasive toothpaste, start with RDA. RDA (Relative Dentin Abrasivity) is a lab score for how much a toothpaste wears away dentin, the softer layer under enamel. The international standard (ISO 11609) and the ADA cap toothpaste at RDA 250, and the FDA uses 200. For anyone with gumline notches, sensitivity or receding gums, Dr. Loukas recommends a paste under RDA 70. Lab research shows toothpaste, not the brush itself, causes this wear: brushing with water alone caused no visible wear.

Toothpaste abrasivity, measured as RDA, is how much a paste scrubs away the dentin under your enamel, and research shows it matters far more than the toothbrush you use. Below is our chart of 73 popular toothpastes, ranked by RDA.

Dr. Thanasi Loukas, DMD
Toothpaste Abrasiveness, Ranked by RDARelative Dentin Abrasion. Higher numbers scrub away more tooth structure.Loukas Dentistry of Park RidgeDr. Thanasi Loukas, DMDdrloukas.comLow, 0 to 70Medium, 71 to 100Highly abrasive, 101 to 150Harmful range, 151 to 250050100150200250FDA limitADA limitPlain water4LowBaking soda7LowProNamel by Sensodyne34LowColgate Regular68LowSensodyne79MediumColgate Sensitive Max Strength83MediumSensodyne Fresh Mint90MediumSensodyne Original100MediumArm & Hammer Sensation103Highly abrasiveCrest Regular110Highly abrasiveAquafresh Whitening113Highly abrasiveColgate Whitening124Highly abrasiveCrest Extra Whitening130Highly abrasiveCrest Pro Health Night140Highly abrasivePepsodent150Highly abrasiveCrest Pro Health155Harmful rangeColgate Tartar Control165Harmful rangeColgate 2 in 1 Tartar/Whitening200Harmful rangeValues are approximate and vary by formula and batch. Ask Dr. Loukas or our hygienist which toothpaste suits you.

The complete RDA chart, all 73 toothpastes

The bar chart above shows the brands people ask about most. This one shows every product in our list, grouped into the four abrasivity bands. It is sized to print, so you are welcome to save it or bring it with you to your next visit.
Toothpaste abrasivity chart listing the RDA of 73 toothpastes grouped into low, medium, highly abrasive and harmful bands
Toothpaste abrasiveness by RDA, grouped into four bands. Open the full size chart to print it or save it to your phone.

Least Abrasive Toothpaste to Most: Ranked by RDA

Relative Dentin Abrasion, lowest to highest

  • 0 to 70, Low abrasive
  • 71 to 100, Medium abrasive
  • 101 to 150, Highly abrasive
  • 151 to 250, Regarded as harmful
RDA Toothpaste Abrasivity
4 Toothbrush with plain water Low abrasive
7 Plain baking soda Low abrasive
8 Arm & Hammer Tooth Powder Low abrasive
15 Weleda Salt Toothpaste Low abrasive
30 Elmex Sensitive Plus Low abrasive
30 Weleda Tooth Products Low abrasive
34 ProNamel by Sensodyne Low abrasive
35 Arm & Hammer Dental Care Low abrasive
42 Arm & Hammer Advanced Whitening/Peroxide Low abrasive
45 Weleda Calendula Toothpaste Low abrasive
45 Weleda Pink Toothpaste with Ratanhia Low abrasive
45 OxyFresh Low abrasive
48 Arm & Hammer Dental Care Sensitive Low abrasive
49 Toms of Maine Sensitive Low abrasive
52 Arm & Hammer Peroxicare Regular Low abrasive
53 Rembrandt Original Low abrasive
53 Closys Low abrasive
54 Arm & Hammer Sensitive + Whitening Low abrasive
54 Arm & Hammer Dental Care PM Bold Mint Low abrasive
57 Toms of Maine
Children’s
Toothpaste Low abrasive
63 Colgate Sensitive Enamel Protect Low abrasive
63 Rembrandt Mint Low abrasive
65 ClinPro Low abrasive
68 Colgate Regular Low abrasive
70 Colgate Total Low abrasive
70 Arm & Hammer Advance White Sensitive Low abrasive
70 Colgate 2 in 1 Fresh Mint Low abrasive
78 Biotene Medium abrasive
79 Sensodyne Medium abrasive
80 Close Up Medium abrasive
83 Colgate Sensitive Max Strength Medium abrasive
84 Toms of Maine Medium abrasive
85 Dentisse Medium abrasive
85 Rembrandt Intense Stain Medium abrasive
87 Natures Gate Medium abrasive
90 Sensodyne Fresh Mint Medium abrasive
91 Aquafresh Sensitive Medium abrasive
92 Sensodyne Cool Gel Medium abrasive
94 Rembrandt Plus Medium abrasive
94 Sensodyne Fresh Impact Medium abrasive
95 Oxyfresh with Fluoride Medium abrasive
100 Sensodyne Original Medium abrasive
100 Sensodyne Tartar Control Whitening Medium abrasive
101 Natural White Highly abrasive
103 Arm & Hammer Sensation Highly abrasive
104 Sensodyne Extra Whitening Highly abrasive
106 Arm & Hammer Advance White Highly abrasive
107 Crest Sensitivity Protection Highly abrasive
107 Sensodyne Full Protection Whitening Highly abrasive
110 Crest Regular Highly abrasive
110 PreviDent 5000 Booster Highly abrasive
110 Colgate Herbal Highly abrasive
113 Aquafresh Whitening Highly abrasive
117 Arm & Hammer Advance White Gel Highly abrasive
117 Arm & Hammer Sensation Tartar Control Highly abrasive
120 Close Up with Baking Soda Highly abrasive
124 Crest Sensitivity Whitening + Scope Highly abrasive
124 Colgate Whitening Highly abrasive
130 Crest Extra Whitening Highly abrasive
133 Ultra Brite Highly abrasive
140 Crest Pro Health Night Highly abrasive
142 Colgate Total Whitening Highly abrasive
145 Crest Pro Health Enamel Shield Highly abrasive
145 Ultra Brite Advanced Whitening Highly abrasive
150 Pepsodent Highly abrasive
152 Crest Sensitive Whitening Regarded as harmful
155 Crest Pro Health Regarded as harmful
160 Colgate Advanced Fresh Regarded as harmful
162 Crest Pro Health Whitening Regarded as harmful
165 Colgate Tartar Control Regarded as harmful
168 Arm & Hammer Dental Care PM Fresh Mint Regarded as harmful
176 Natures Gate Paste Regarded as harmful
200 Colgate 2 in 1 Tartar Control/Whitening Regarded as harmful
200 FDA upper limit
250 ADA upper limit

Values compiled from published RDA lists, including Rath et al. 2016, and manufacturer literature. Published values for the same brand can differ between sources and change when formulas change, so treat these numbers as approximate. Ask Dr. Loukas or our hygienist which toothpaste is right for you.

If you run a fingernail along the gumline of your own teeth and feel a notch or a groove, you are feeling toothbrush abrasion. It shows up as a wedge shaped dent right where the enamel meets the root, usually on the cheek side, and most often on the canines and premolars. Patients notice it because those spots turn sensitive to cold, or because the tooth starts to look longer and darker near the gum. The name is slightly unfair to the toothbrush. Research points at what is on the brush rather than the brush itself.

Watch: Dr. Loukas explains toothpaste abrasion and electric toothbrushes in our toothpaste abrasion video.

What the research actually found

The study most often cited here is Dzakovich and Oslak, published in the Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry in 2008. They set out to reproduce these cervical notches in the laboratory, and they succeeded. The important part is how. Brushing with a toothbrush and water did not carve the lesions. Brushing with toothpaste did, which points to toothpaste abrasivity as the main cause. The abrasive particles suspended in the paste are what remove tooth structure. The bristles are the delivery system, not the cutting tool. That matters because these notches are commonly blamed on clenching and grinding instead. A narrative review by Fan and Caton for the 2017 World Workshop on the Classification of Periodontal Diseases, published in 2018, concluded there is no credible evidence for abfraction, the idea that biting force flexes teeth and causes these notches, or that it causes gum recession. Grinding is a real problem and we treat it, but if you have notches at the gumline, the first thing worth examining is the tube in your bathroom.

How to check your toothpaste abrasivity

Every toothpaste carries an RDA value, short for Relative Dentin Abrasivity. It is a laboratory measure of how much tooth structure a paste removes compared with a standard reference. The international standard ISO 11609 and the ADA set the upper limit at 250, and the FDA uses 200. That ceiling is a safety limit, not a recommendation, and it sits far above what we suggest for anyone who already shows wear.

Charcoal pastes are the least predictable group on this list. Published values run from gentler than Colgate Regular to close to the most abrasive whitening pastes, and the tube rarely tells you which you bought.

Whitening toothpaste and abrasivity

Whitening toothpaste does not bleach the tooth. It scrubs surface stain off, which is why its toothpaste abrasivity is usually higher. On an intact enamel surface that is a reasonable trade. On an exposed root surface it is not, because root dentin is far softer than enamel and gives way much faster. People with receding gums are often the same people reaching for a whitening paste, which is the worst pairing of the two. If your goal is a brighter shade rather than stain removal, professional teeth whitening in Park Ridge lightens the tooth itself and costs you no tooth structure.

What Dr. Loukas recommends

If you already have gumline notches, lowering your toothpaste abrasivity is the single easiest change you can make.
  • A paste under RDA 70 if you have any gumline notching, sensitivity or recession.
  • A soft or extra soft brush. Medium and hard bristles have no advantage and do real harm.
  • Light pressure. If the bristles splay outward while you brush, you are pressing far too hard.
  • Small circles or short strokes rather than long horizontal scrubbing across the gumline.
  • Wait at least 30 minutes after anything acidic. Enamel softens briefly after citrus, soda or wine, and brushing during that window removes more than it would otherwise.

Five Rules to Protect Gumline Enamel

5 Rules to Protect Gumline Enamel

  1. Choose a low abrasive toothpaste. Ask us and we will recommend one.
  2. Use a soft or extra soft brush head.
  3. Use a feather light grip, fingertips only, and do not scrub.
  4. Wait at least 30 minutes after acidic foods or drinks before brushing.
  5. Replace your brush head every three months.

If you grind or clench, a custom night guard may help protect against abfraction, while a low abrasive toothpaste helps protect against abrasion. Learn more about TMJ treatment and night guards and checkups and cleanings in Park Ridge.

Video transcript

If you use an electric toothbrush, have sensitive teeth, or see your gums pulling back, the problem may not be your brush. It may be your toothpaste. Research shows the gritty particles in toothpaste are a major cause of tooth wear at the gumline. I'm Dr. Thanasi Loukas, a dentist in Park Ridge, Illinois, and in the next few minutes I'll show you how to protect your teeth. Not all tooth damage is a cavity. Dentists see notches and worn spots right at the gumline, we call these noncarious cervical lesions. "Noncarious" means no decay. The tooth structure is simply being worn away. Once it's gone, it doesn't grow back. Every toothpaste has an abrasiveness rating called RDA, Relative Dentin Abrasivity. It measures how much the paste wears down dentin, the softer layer under your enamel. The industry limit is 250. Whitening and "tartar control" pastes are often on the higher end. Many dentists consider under about 70 to be low abrasive. Laboratory studies show that tooth wear depends mostly on the toothpaste, the brush itself causes very little. In one long term simulation, power toothbrushes paired with a highly abrasive toothpaste caused significantly more dentin wear than a manual brush at the same force. Other studies found that higher abrasive pastes and stiffer bristles create deeper, wedge shaped notches at the gumline. A lot of my patients tell me, "My brush has a pressure light, so I'm safe." That sensor only tells you if you're pushing too hard. It doesn't know what toothpaste you're using. An electric brush makes thousands of movements per minute, pair that with a gritty paste, and you can still wear down your teeth while the light never turns on. You need to be especially careful if you have: Gum recession, exposed root surfaces, which are much softer than enamel. Sensitivity to cold or brushing. Grinding or clenching, the flexing of teeth may make the gumline more vulnerable. That's called abfraction. Or you simply want to keep your enamel for life. Here's something most people don't know. Abrasion and abfraction are not the same thing. Abrasion is wear from scrubbing and gritty toothpaste. Abfraction comes from grinding and clenching. The tooth flexes and tiny cracks form right at the gumline. Once that area is weakened by abfraction, abrasion can wear it away much faster. That's why if you grind or clench, a custom night guard may help protect against abfraction and a low abrasive toothpaste helps protect against abrasion. Together they protect your gumline. Here's my advice. One, choose a low abrasive toothpaste. Ask us and we'll recommend one. Two, use a soft or extra soft brush head. Three, with an electric brush, use a feather light grip. Hold it with your fingertips and let the brush do the work. Don't scrub. Four, if you've just had something acidic, like soda, wine, or citrus, wait at least 30 minutes before brushing. Five, replace your brush head every three months. Everyone's mouth is different. At your exam visit, my hygienist and I will check for early wear and recession, look at your toothpaste and brush, and show you the right technique for your teeth. Small changes now can save you from fillings, sensitivity, and gum grafts later. If you're in Park Ridge or nearby, schedule your visit with us at Loukas Dentistry. And subscribe for more tips. I'm Dr. Loukas, take care of your smile!

The five rules, in 60 seconds.

Electric toothbrushes and toothpaste abrasivity

An electric brush is usually a help rather than a hazard, as long as you pair it with low toothpaste abrasivity, because most of them have a pressure sensor and because the head does the work for you. The risk is pressing the moving head into the gumline out of habit carried over from a manual brush. Rest it against the tooth and let it run. If your brush has a pressure light, treat it as a last warning rather than a target. The sensor is calibrated for an average paste; if yours sits higher on the RDA chart, or you have recession and exposed dentin, you need to stay well below the pressure that sets it off. With recession, a soft manual brush used with a gentle sweeping motion away from the gums, upward on the lower teeth and downward on the upper teeth, is often the easier way to keep both pressure and direction under control.
Electric brush plus abrasive paste: what we see at the gumline, in 60 seconds.

How we check for this at your visit

Cervical wear is easy to miss because it is painless until it is not. At a checkup and cleaning we look at the gumline on every tooth, measure recession, and compare against your previous records to see whether a notch is deepening. Shallow wear is managed by changing the paste and the technique. Deeper notches that have reached dentin are usually restored with a tooth colored filling that seals the surface and stops the sensitivity. If clenching turns out to be part of the picture, that is treated separately. See TMJ and jaw pain treatment in Park Ridge.

Frequently asked questions

Is my toothbrush ruining my teeth?

Not on its own. Laboratory work shows a brush used with water alone does not carve cervical notches. The abrasive in the toothpaste is what removes tooth structure, and pressure and technique decide how fast.

What RDA should I look for?

Under 70 is a sensible target if you already have gumline wear, recession or sensitivity. The ADA permits up to 250, but that is a safety ceiling rather than a recommendation.

Is charcoal toothpaste safe?

It is unpredictable. A 2023 lab study of 12 charcoal toothpastes measured RDA values from 26 to 166, so two tubes on the same shelf can behave completely differently (Zoller et al., Int J Dent Hyg 2023). Many contain no fluoride either.

Can toothbrush abrasion be reversed?

The lost tooth structure does not grow back. What we can do is stop the wear getting worse and restore the notch with bonding when it is deep or sensitive.

Why are my teeth sensitive to cold at the gumline?

Usually because enamel has worn through to dentin, which carries tubules that run to the nerve. Worth having looked at, because the same symptom can also point to recession, a crack or decay.

What type of toothpaste should I use?

For most adults, a fluoride toothpaste with an RDA under 70 is the safe default. If you have recession, sensitivity or visible notches at the gumline, choose a low abrasivity sensitivity formula with fluoride and keep whitening pastes for occasional use rather than every day, because most whitening formulas sit higher on the chart. Check the chart above, pick a paste in the low range, and bring the tube to your next visit if you are unsure.

I have gum recession. What should I change about how I brush?

Three things. Switch to a low RDA fluoride toothpaste, because the exposed root surface is dentin and it wears far faster than enamel. Lighten your grip to the point where the bristles barely bend. And stop scrubbing back and forth across the gumline. Once a root is exposed, the combination of an abrasive paste, firm pressure and a horizontal scrubbing motion is what carves the notch.

Should I trust the pressure sensor on my electric toothbrush?

Treat it as a last warning, not a target. The sensor is set for an average paste and an average mouth. If you are using a higher abrasivity toothpaste, or you have recession and exposed dentin, you need to stay well below the pressure that triggers the light or the alarm. Hold the handle with your fingertips, rest the head against the tooth, and let the brush do the work. If the sensor ever goes off, you were already pressing too hard for your situation.

Is a manual or an electric toothbrush better if I have recession or toothbrush abrasion?

Either can be safe and either can cause damage. An electric brush removes plaque with less effort and most models warn you about pressure, but people often push the moving head into the gumline out of habit. A soft manual brush used with a gentle sweeping motion away from the gums gives you full control over pressure and direction, and for many patients with recession Dr. Loukas finds it the easier way to protect exposed roots. What matters most is a soft brush, a low RDA paste, light pressure and the right motion.

What brushing technique helps prevent toothbrush abrasion?

Sweep away from the gums rather than scrubbing across them. On the lower teeth, angle the bristles toward the gumline and sweep upward, from the gum toward the biting edge. On the upper teeth, sweep downward, from the gum toward the biting edge. This rolling motion lifts plaque away from the gumline instead of grinding paste into the exposed root surface. Use a soft brush, a light grip and a low abrasivity fluoride toothpaste, and spend about two minutes covering every surface.

What is the difference between gum recession and toothbrush abrasion?

Recession is the gum moving down the root so that root surface is exposed. Abrasion is the loss of tooth structure that follows, when an abrasive toothpaste is rubbed back and forth across that exposed dentin by the brush. Recession opens the door, abrasion carves the notch. Clenching and grinding can add a third factor called abfraction, where flexing of the tooth chips away the same area. All three show up at the gumline and all three are checked at your exam, because the treatment differs.

Not sure whether your toothpaste is the problem?

Bring the tube to your next visit and we will look at the gumline together. Call (847) 696-1919 or request an appointment. We see patients from Park Ridge and the surrounding area.

Can an electric toothbrush wear down your teeth?

The brush itself causes very little wear in laboratory studies. Most wear at the gumline comes from the abrasive particles in toothpaste, especially when combined with a power brush, heavy pressure or stiff bristles.

What is RDA in toothpaste?

RDA, Relative Dentin Abrasivity, rates how much a toothpaste wears down dentin. The industry limit is 250, and many dentists consider an RDA under about 70 to be low abrasive.

What is the difference between abrasion and abfraction?

Abrasion is wear from scrubbing and gritty toothpaste. Abfraction comes from grinding and clenching, which flexes the tooth and can create small cracks at the gumline. Once abfraction weakens that area, abrasion can wear it away faster.

Does a night guard help with gumline notches?

If you grind or clench, a custom night guard may help protect against abfraction, and a low abrasive toothpaste helps protect against abrasion. Your dentist can check for early wear at your exam visit.

Further reading: “3D Image analysis of the impact of toothpaste abrasivity on the progression of simulated non carious cervical lesions,” Journal of Dentistry, 2018. This video is for general education and is not a substitute for an exam.

Related reading

References

  1. Dzakovich JJ, Oslak RR. In vitro reproduction of noncarious cervical lesions. J Prosthet Dent. 2008;100(1):1-10. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18589068/
  2. Fan J, Caton JG. Occlusal trauma and excessive occlusal forces: narrative review, case definitions, and diagnostic considerations. J Periodontol. 2018;89 Suppl 1:S214-S222. Also published in J Clin Periodontol. 2018;45 Suppl 20:S199-S206. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29926498/
  3. Rath SK, Sharma V, Pratap CB, Chaturvedi TP. Abrasivity of dentifrices: an update. SRM J Res Dent Sci. 2016;7(2):96-100. https://drdroter.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Rath-Toothpaste-Abrasiveness-2016.pdf
  4. Zoller MJ, Hamza B, Cucuzza C, Gubler A, Attin T, Wegehaupt FJ. Relative dentin and enamel abrasivity of charcoal toothpastes. Int J Dent Hyg. 2023;21:149-156. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10099862/
  5. International Organization for Standardization. ISO 11609: Dentistry, dentifrices, requirements, test methods and marking.
  6. Joiner A. Whitening toothpastes: a review of the literature. J Dent. 2010;38 Suppl 2:e17-e24.
author avatar
Dr. Thanasi Loukas, DMD General & Cosmetic Dentist (DMD)
Dr. Thanasi M. Loukas, DMD is a graduate of Tufts University School of Dental Medicine and the owner of Loukas Dentistry of Park Ridge, Illinois, a family practice founded in 1981. Dr. Loukas focuses on dental implant surgery and restoration, Invisalign clear aligners, cosmetic dentistry, bone grafting, oral surgery, emergency dentistry, and facial aesthetics including Botox, dermal fillers, PDO threads, and Kybella. He uses advanced 3D CBCT imaging and digital guided implant planning to deliver precise, predictable outcomes for patients across Park Ridge.